It is important to understand that this is not only about Google–and not only about Italy. Similar legal cases took place in other countries, involving companies such as Ebay or Yahoo. Not surprisingly, providers are now trying to cope with uncertainty in the only available way: through censorship.
Daniel H. Kahn, a recent Harvard School of Law graduate and clerk on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, discusses social intermediaries and their potential to radically improve the social life of the Web. The discussion also turns to portable identities, code-backed norms, and trolling.
Under the current proposal in Itay, websites like YouTube or Vimeo that stream video over the internet would be required to seek a Government license and to prevent users from uploading illegal content through their infrastructure.
Google’s new Sidewiki tool allows users to annotate any page on the web. It is essentially a private fairness doctrine for the web a la Cass Sunstein’s “electronic sidewalks.”